Many of us know the Thanksgiving story we heard as schoolchildren: the Pilgrims and nearby friendly Wampanoag Indians in Plymouth, Mass., took part in a harvest feast in 1621 to celebrate the colony’s survival of a first harsh and tragic year that launched the November tradition as we know it.
But Wampanoag descendants tell a different version – which not only furthers the tradition’s dubious origins, but obscures the inevitable war between the colonials and the Indians.
When the Pilgrims arrived at Plymouth Harbor in December 1620, they were just in time to endure a disease-ridden, scarce-food winter that wiped out nearly half of the colony’s 102 inhabitants.
If the names Massasoit, Squanto, and Samoset ring any grade-school bells, it was through them and an alliance with the Wampanoags that the remaining members of the colony learned to plant spring and summer crops which took hold; and, along with area game and fish, yielded a harvest in 1621 that was as bountiful as the previous winter had been bleak.
As Dr. David J. Silverman, professor of early America, native America at George Washington University said in his book ‘This Land Is Their Land’, ‘Having passed through one crisis after another, Plymouth’s leaders decided that sometime in late September or early October, after the harvest was in, the people should set aside some time to “rejoice together.”’
But despite their military alliance with the colonists and their critical help in yielding the harvest, the Indians were not invited to this day of eating, merrymaking, and various forms of recreation.
They came only because, as Silverman writes, one of the colonists’ recreations included ‘militia drill and target practice.’
The Indians heard the shooting and thought the colony was under attack from a neighboring hostile tribe or the nearby French. So 90 Wampanoags grabbed their weapons and suddenly arrived at the gate of the settlement, looking every inch to the 53 colonists as if ready for battle.
‘In almost any other time and place, a surprise encounter like this between so many armed colonists and Indians would have cost lives,’ Silverman writes. ‘Yet the two people possessed just enough trust in each other that no one overreacted.’
Plymouth Governor William Bradford’s account of the encounter is inconclusive: He mentions only that ‘we exercised our Armes, many of the Indians coming amongst us, and amongst the rest their greatest king Massasoyt, with some ninetie men, whom for three dayes we entertained and feasted.’
As to the handed-down version of the feast, Silverman credits Rev. Alexander Young, an American historian and Unitarian minister who published a four-line account in 1841, labeling it ‘the first Thanksgiving’ – an assumption put forth long after the fact, and one that neither the Pilgrims nor the Indians intended.
Over the next 50 years, Silverman writes, ‘various authors, artists, and lecturers disseminated Young’s idea until Americans took it for granted.’
But despite our preference to remember the event as described by Young, it doesn’t change the actual record: Relations between the colonials and the Indians were tentative and steadily deteriorated over successive generations – and that the feast has no historical connection to our modern holiday.
“Thanksgiving doesn’t derive from the event,” Silverman said. “You can’t separate the fact that the Wampanoags and the English fought a genocidal war within 50 years of this shared celebration – It almost broke out several times before that. And that war is more representative of relations between the colonials and the Indians than any shared feast.”
